Fill in the application form and start selling

How to defend a chargeback with evidence

Which evidence works for each chargeback reason at PayOk

Evidence by chargeback reason, covering fraud, not received, not as described and subscription

A defense can fail even when the sale was legitimate if relevant evidence is missing or is sent too late. If you have already received the notice, this guide explains how to defend a chargeback at PayOk with documents that answer what the cardholder claims.

  • How to read the reason given by the cardholder's bank.
  • Which evidence usually helps for each reason.
  • How to upload it through your dashboard and the deadline for doing so.
  • When to talk to support before defending the sale.

Why does the reason decide how to defend a chargeback?

The chargeback reason decides which evidence works, because your documents must answer what the cardholder claims and meet the card network's requirements. For example, delivery does not prove on its own that the cardholder authorised the payment, although it can be part of the evidence against certain fraud claims.

Each card network has its list of reasons, each with a code. Visa uses codes such as 10.4 or 13.1, and Mastercard numbers such as 4837 or 4853. At PayOk you see the reason in the notice email and in the transaction details, with the network, the code and its description.

PayOk is a payment institution registered with the Bank of Spain under number 6928. It is not a direct acquirer and is not directly connected to the card networks. It relies on a financial institution that acts as acquirer. If you want to know what happens to your money during the dispute, see what to do when you receive a chargeback.

Evidence that usually works, reason by reason

This table sums up the evidence that usually helps for the most common reasons. Documents are assessed under the network rules and, if the disagreement reaches arbitration, Visa or Mastercard decides. Provide relevant, legible documents that are sufficient to address the stated reason.

ReasonCodes PayOk may showWhat the cardholder claimsEvidence that usually helps
Card-absent fraudVisa 10.4, Mastercard 4837That they did not make or authorise the purchase3D Secure authentication result, IP and device, matching name and address, previous purchases by the same customer
Not receivedVisa 13.1, Mastercard 4855 or 4853That they paid and did not receive the goods or serviceProof of delivery with tracking, date and address, or access log for the digital service
Not as describedVisa 13.3, Mastercard 4853That what they received was not as described or was defectiveProduct description and photos on your website, accepted terms, conversations with the customer
Cancelled subscriptionVisa 13.2, Mastercard 4841 or 4853That they cancelled and kept being chargedAccepted terms, charge date and a record of the cancellation requests and how they were handled
Credit not processedVisa 13.6, Mastercard 4860 or 4853That a credit or cancellation they were due has not been processedProof of the credit or cancellation, or documents that rebut that specific reason
Duplicate chargeVisa 12.6.1That they were charged twice for the same thingSeparate orders and invoices showing they were two purchases

Mastercard groups several cardholder disagreements under code 4853, and PayOk's catalogue also accepts older codes such as 4855, 4841 and 4860. Always check the code and description shown in your case. A refund policy does not replace on its own a credit the customer was entitled to.

📌 Answer the specific reason, not the customer's whole story. A few relevant pieces of evidence help more than many unrelated to the reason.

Fraud chargebacks and the authentication result

If the purchase was authenticated with 3D Secure, provide that result. Shifting liability to the issuing bank depends on the network's requirements and on the outcome of the transaction, and strong customer authentication and 3D Secure are not the same thing. The first is the legal obligation and 3D Secure is the protocol used to meet it in card payments. Without authentication, the purchase data count, such as the IP, the device, the delivery address and whether that customer had bought before without problems.

Friendly fraud also comes in here, a claim on a legitimate purchase, which may come from confusion or from a deliberate attempt to get the money back. Evidence of participation, delivery or use can help depending on the reason and the network's requirements, although it does not guarantee a favourable outcome.

Goods not received or not as described, where logistics decides

In chargebacks for goods not received, proof of delivery with a tracking number is usually the key piece. Selling without stock or with uncertain delivery times increases the risk of this kind of claim.

If the customer says the product was not as advertised, provide the product page as it was on the day of purchase, the terms they accepted and the conversations in which you offered them a solution.

Examples of defense by type of business

These examples are illustrative and show which documents answer each situation.

  • Online shop selling physical goods. A customer claims they did not receive the order. The defense relies on the tracking number, the delivery date and address, and the shipping confirmation emails.
  • Digital service or subscription. A customer says they cancelled. What counts is the accepted terms, the charge date and records of their access to the service and their cancellation requests.
  • Bookings and services scheduled for a particular date. A customer disputes a deposit. The booking confirmation, the cancellation terms they accepted and your communications with them help.

How to upload your evidence at PayOk, step by step

  1. Open the transaction. Under Transactions, find the sale with the status Charged back and open its details.
  2. Check the reason and the deadline. They are in the case, together with the case reference and the stage.
  3. Prepare your documents. Formats PDF, JPG or PNG, up to 5 MB each and a maximum of 10. Put related screenshots into a single PDF so you don't hit the limit.
  4. Upload them with the Upload document button, in the Defense documents section. You can do it before the deadline and while the case is still open.
  5. Follow the case stage. We show it in the same details page until it is closed as won or lost.

If you prefer, you can also send the documents by replying to the notice email or writing to support. In the dashboard you can see the case documents and who uploaded them, you or PayOk. After the deadline, the dashboard no longer accepts new documents.

Add a short one-page summary to your evidence that explains the sale in order, with what was bought, when, how it was delivered and what contact there was with the customer. That way whoever reviews the dispute understands your case faster.

📌 Do not include the full card number in your evidence. Before sending the file, remove the card number so that it cannot be recovered. The PCI DSS standard requires it to be protected and forbids sending it unprotected by email.

When to talk to support before defending

Defending a chargeback makes sense when you have evidence that answers the reason. If the claim is justified and you have no evidence to rebut it, for example because the order never left the warehouse, ask support how to proceed.

Before a chargeback exists, our rule is simple. Make refunds easy when they are due. Putting obstacles in the way of a due refund or leaving a complaint unanswered can turn a solvable problem into a chargeback, with its fee and its impact on your history.

📌 With a chargeback already open, do not make another refund on that sale on your own. Talk to support first so the customer does not get the money twice.

To reduce them before they arrive, you have a full action plan in our guide to preventing and disputing chargebacks and a checklist in the 20-step e-commerce audit.

Frequently asked questions about defending a chargeback

Which documents work to defend a chargeback?

It depends on the reason. The usual ones are the invoice, proof of delivery or of access to the service, the accepted terms and the conversations with the customer. If 3D Secure was used, the authentication result.

What is the deadline for submitting evidence?

Until the deadline shown in the notice email and in the transaction details, while the case is still open. After that, the dashboard does not accept new documents.

Can I send the evidence by email instead of through the dashboard?

Yes. You can reply to the notice email or write to support, always before the deadline. In the dashboard you see the case documents and who uploaded them.

What is friendly fraud in a chargeback?

It is a claim on a legitimate purchase, from cardholder confusion or a deliberate attempt to get the money back. Evidence of delivery, use or participation can help, although it does not guarantee winning.

Does 3D Secure help win a chargeback?

It can help in certain fraud chargebacks if the transaction meets the network's requirements. It does not guarantee winning, and for goods not received, not as described or defective what counts is proof of delivery and of what was sold.

Next step

Winning chargebacks does not depend on luck, but on what you keep on the day of the sale. Check today whether your shop keeps the proof of delivery, the IP and the accepted terms of every order. If you have an open chargeback, go to Transactions, check its deadline and upload your evidence. For any questions, write to us at [email protected].

Sources and further reading

Was this post useful?

Leave a Comment